You May Like
Vintage Commonwealth toy & novelty co inc 1987 New York NY stuffed bear
$16.00
View Details
Vintage 1987 commonwealth toy novelty co stuffed animal smoking cigar
$11.99
View Details
VTG Tan Bunny Rabbit Lop Ears Plush Pink Bow 1999 Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co
$24.99
View Details
Commonwealth toy &novelty Co tan bunny rabbit lop ears plush pink bow 1999
$35.99
View Details
Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co. 16" Bunny Plush Stuffed Animal with Pink Bow-1988
$15.00
View Details
Vintage Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co 1989 Little Girl Doll Suzy dark color 17"
$6.39
View Details
Vintage Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co Vintage Blue Stuffed Pig Piggy Bank
$25.00
View Details
Rudolph The Red Nose Reindeer Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co 2006
$10.80
View Details
Sunburst Pets Bear Cub By Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co Vintage 1983 App 12"
$13.99
View Details
Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co Inc 01-01-00 Millanimals Mugsy The Mutt Plush Used
$13.50
View Details
Vtg 1987 Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co. Dog White Plush Soft Stuffed Animal 13”
$26.99
View Details
1987 Commonwealth Toy Novelty Co Hound Stuffed Animal Smoking Cigar
$14.00
View Details
Vintage Pac-Man Plush Puppet with Ghost - Commonwealth Toy Novelty Co 1982
$99.00
View Details
Vtg🦄The Bialosky Treasury CommonWealth Toy & Novelty Co. Teddy Bear 18" Plush!
$158.00
View Details
Sugar Plum Junction Santa Claus Stuffed Plush Doll Commonwealth Toy Novelty Co
$44.99
View Details
Vintage 90's Commonwealth Toy & Novelty CO. White Bear W/ Green & Red Bow
$19.99
View Details
Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co Plush Dog Puppy Hand Puppet Vintage 1989
$6.00
View Details
Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co. plush white sno-ball snowball stuffed animal
$9.07
View Details
Vintage Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co Inc Millanimals Baby Mildred Plush
$8.00
View Details
Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co Black Cat Plush Vintage Pounce Stance
$9.50
View Details
Square Cube Chick Plush • Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co • 2017
$12.00
View Details
Vintage Commonwealth Toy and Novelty Co Duck-A-Ling Musical Plush
$23.72
View Details
Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co.,Inc.,Nitey-Nite, Cow, Red, Black, Plaid, Pajamas
$14.99
View Details
Vintage Christmas Elf 1984 Commonwealth & Toy Novelty Co. Musical Jingle Bells
$19.99
View Details
1991 Commonwealth Plush Bear Toy & Novelty Co 18" Teddy Bear Stuffed Animal, VTG
$20.00
View Details
commonwealth toy & novelty co. vintage stuffed reindeer 30 Inch great condition
$13.00
View Details
Vintage 1982 Le Harve Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co. INC Crocodile
$14.99
View Details
RARE Vintage Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co Broom Stick Riding Horse Pony Plush
$34.95
View Details
Sugar Plum Junction Santa Claus Plush Commonwealth Toy Novelty Co. | SANTA PLUSH
$45.99
View Details
Angry Birds Atlanta Braves Plush Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co. 2014 Baseball
$16.00
View Details
Commonwealth Gorilla Plush Stuffed Animal Vintage 1988 Ape Toy & Novelty Co
$25.00
View Details
Vtg. 🦄CommonWealth Toy & Novelty Co. Calico Cat Blue Eyes w/Bow 1990 12" Plush!
$148.00
View Details
1960'S VINTAGE BROWN APE PLUSH W/ RUBBER FACE COMMONWEALTH TOY & NOVELTY CO. 9"
$16.79
View Details
Vintage Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co. Sea Lion Plush Stuffed Animal Seal
$24.99
View Details
Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co. Vintage 1990’s Caramel & Ivory Sitting Kitty Cat
$24.95
View Details
Vintage Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co. Rubber Face Sleeping Baby With Pillow 11”
$28.50
View Details
Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co Inc 01-01-00 Millanimals Mugsy The Mutt Plush
$22.49
View Details
Tummy Mums Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co. 1988 Hasbro Plush 13in Made in Korea
$11.99
View Details
Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co. Ted - Coffee Mug With Sound
$39.71
View Details
Vintage Rudy Wishmas 1988 Plush Reindeer, Commonwealth Toy And Novelty Co
$60.00
View Details
Vintage Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co. Blue plush elephant
$9.99
View Details
EXC Vintage 1991 Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co. Green Rattlesnake w Bow Tie
$16.99
View Details
Vintage Dog Plush Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co., 1985
$12.40
View Details
Christmas Lights Puppy - Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Company - New in Package
$13.93
View Details
Commonwealth Toy and Novelty Co Teddy Bear Stuffed Animal Plush Green Plaid Bow
$9.95
View Details
Vintage Commonwealth Hugging Parrot Toy Novelty Co Large Bird Hand Puppet READ
$17.49
View Details
BUNDE PLUSH CAT COMMONWEALTH TOY & NOVELTY CO NY COLLECTABLE 2000 NEW WITH TAG
$7.99
View Details
Velveteen Rabbit Set Toys R Us Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co 9" Vintage 1985
$29.99
View Details
Saks Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co. Teddy Bear In Blue & White Striped Sweater
$8.00
View Details
Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co., Inc. Stuffed Animal Plush Dog Used
$15.00
View Details
Peeps Pink Plush chick Easter Basket 9” x 11” Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co
$24.76
View Details
Angry Birds Chuck Yellow Bird Plush Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co No Sound
$12.99
View Details
Deb B Polar Pear Deb Exclusive 90's Purple Hoodie Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co
$59.99
View Details
VTG Comic Strip DILBERT Plush 9.5" T by Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co.
$6.77
View Details
Angry Birds Red Plush Stuffee 2010 Retired 6" Tall Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co
$7.86
View Details
Vint Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co. plush St. Saint Bernard puppy dog old plush
$19.99
View Details
Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co Inc 01-01-00 Millanimals Mugsy The Mutt Plush
$16.00
View Details
Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co Vintage 1991 Yellow and Green 6" Plush Frog
$20.99
View Details
Commonwealth 1990 Plush Velvet Santa 13.5in Toy And Novelty Company NY 
$13.99
View Details
Sugar Plum Junction Santa Claus Stuffed Plush Doll Commonwealth Toy Novelty Co
$22.99
View Details
Vintage 1980s Christmas Elf Commonwealth & Toy Novelty Co. Musical Jingle Bells
$16.75
View Details
Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co Vintage Plush Mouse Colorful Plaid Bow Tie Stuffie
$24.99
View Details
Vintage Commonwealth Rubber Face Gorilla 9" Plush Toy and Novelty Co Stuffed Toy
$29.99
View Details
I Love You Teddy Bear - Perfect For Valentine’s Day Commonwealth Toy Novelty Co
$8.00
View Details
Commonwealth Toys Novelty Co 2006 PINK 16" EASTER Bunny Plush Stuffed Animal EUC
$27.50
View Details
Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co. Plush Teddy Bear w/ Rose on Top, 9", Cream
$9.00
View Details
Vintage Commonwealth Rubber Face Gorilla 9" Plush Toy and Novelty Co Stuffed Toy
$24.99
View Details
RARE Vintage Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co Broom Stick Riding Witch Plush!
$150.00
View Details
Sugar Plum Junction Santa Claus Stuffed Plush Doll Commonwealth Toy Novelty Co
$63.75
View Details
Dilbert Dog 11" Plush United Features Syndicate Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co.
$10.00
View Details
Angry Birds Plush Backpack Clip - Red Bird, New, Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co.
$6.90
View Details
Vintage Commonwealth Lush Plush Toy & Novelty Co 18" Teddy Bear Stuffed Animal
$22.70
View Details
2010 Angry Birds Red Bird 8" plush by Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co. No sound.
$6.32
View Details
Dalmatian dog plush toy stuffed animal commonwealth toy and novelty co. 1993
$10.00
View Details
Angry Birds Movie - 7” Bomb Stuffed Toy (Commonwealth Toy + Novelty Co)
$10.99
View Details
Vintage Commonwealth Toy And Novelty Co 1989 Rag Doll Deb B
$5.00
View Details
ANGRY BIRDS Red Bird 6" Plush 2010 Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co. Inc.
$7.00
View Details
RARE Vintage Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co Broom Stick Riding Horse Pony Plush
$150.00
View Details
vintage1966 Batman Plush Toy DC/Commonwealth Toy and Novelty Company doll figure
$49.99
View Details
Vintage Commonwealth Toy And Novelty Co 1989 Rag Doll Stuffed Animal Toy
$15.50
View Details
2000 Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co. 11” Plush Yellow Bunny In Wooden Wagon Toy
$30.00
View Details
Sugar Plum Junction Santa Claus 19" Plush Doll Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co
$24.99
View Details
Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Plush Porcelain Face Doll Dressed as Teddy Bear, 1991
$5.00
View Details
14" Red Nose Moose 1988 Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co Plush
$16.24
View Details
Teddybear brand Commonwealth Toy and Novelty Co.
$9.00
View Details
Sugar Plum Junction Santa Claus 19" Plush Doll Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co
$24.99
View Details
Vintage Commonwealth & Novelty Co. Yellow Sleepy Stuffed Easter Bunny (PL24)
$25.00
View Details
Ted 2 - 16 inch Animated Plush Scuba Outfit - Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co.
$89.42
View Details
Commowealth Toy & Novelty Co. Sno-Ball Plush White with Ear Warmers Toy
$21.00
View Details
Angry Birds Movie - 7” Stella Stuffed Toy (Commonwealth Toy + Novelty Co)
$10.99
View Details
Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co Vintage 1991 Yellow and Blue 6" Plush Frog W/ Bow
$25.00
View Details
Angry Birds Plush Yellow 10” Chuck 2010 Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co No Sound
$17.99
View Details
Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co Big Large Plush Mouse - 1989 - Vintage.
$10.41
View Details
Angry Birds Movie - 7” Mighty Eagle Stuffed Toy (Commonwealth Toy + Novelty Co)
$12.99
View Details
Vtg 8" Ape Monkey Plush Stuffed Animal Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Lush Plush
$16.50
View Details
Duck Dynasty - 24 inch Phil Plush with Sound - Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co.
$53.96
View Details
Vintage Commonwealth Toy and Novelty Company Bear 12" - BIN75
$15.75
View Details
COMMONWEALTH 2001 Toy and Novelty CO INC, NY THE NETHERLAND
$12.50
View Details
Angry Birds Plush Yellow 9" Stuffee 2010 Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co No Sound
$19.99
View Details
Ted Pillow with Sound (R-Rated) - 14 Inches - Commonwealth Toy & Novelty Co.
$52.09
View Details