You May Like
2023 Topps Sebathia/Pettitte One-Two Punch Dual Auto /25
$350.00
View Details
1909 T206 Rube Manning Pitching PSA 2 GD MC Sweet Caporal 350 / 30 Baseball Card
$99.99
View Details
Roger Clemens and Andy Pettitte /150 2024 Topps Tribute Dual Relic Yankees
$29.99
View Details
2024 Topps Tribute Dual Relic Roger Clemens/Gerrit Cole #/75 - Yankees Game Used
$20.00
View Details
GERRIT COLE 2022 TOPPS TIER ONE GAME USED PATCH YANKEES /399 Q2273
$6.00
View Details
Andy Pettitte & CC Sabathia 2023 Topps 1-2 Punch Insert #12P-4 Yankees
$0.99
View Details
2020 Topps Series 1 / Series 2 / Update DECADES BEST You Pick the Card
$1.25
View Details
New York Yankees Pitcher 7 Lot MLB Baseball + 2" Sticker Topps Cortes Rodon +
$1.42
View Details
2020 Topps Decades' Best #DB-73 Andy Pettitte New York Yankees
$1.49
View Details
1985 Yankees Pitcher Set Joe Cowley #769 AND Clay Christiansen #211
$1.25
View Details
Whitey Ford 2020 Topps Decades’ Best Blue DB-11 Yankees
$2.49
View Details
Ron Guidry 2 Card Lot Pitcher New York Yankees 1980 Topps #250 1981 Donruss #227
$2.69
View Details
2005 Donruss Throwback Threads Hit Bunt to Pitcher-Out /35 Randy Johnson HOF
$34.18
View Details
1976 Topps Ron Guidry RC New York Yankees #599
$16.49
View Details
2024 Topps Series 2 💥 Randy Johnson 💥Green Foil 💎/99 New York Yankees
$16.14
View Details
Joe Verbanic 1970 Topps New York Yankees Pitcher #416
$27.50
View Details
2020 Topps Series 2 Decade's Best Insert Baseball Card Complete Your Set U Pick
$2.99
View Details
2020 Topps Decades' Best #DB-74 Roger Clemens New York Yankees
$1.49
View Details
Jordan Montgomery 2022 Topps Series 2 Baseball #382 MLB New York Yankees Pitcher
$1.20
View Details
1983 TCMA 50 Years of Yankee All-Stars Robert Simon Pick From List Up To 25% OFF
$0.99
View Details
1997 Score Pitcher Perfect Wade Boggs New York Yankees #13
$0.99
View Details
2X 1997 METAL UNIVERSE Mariano Rivera SANDMAN Pitcher New York Yankees 122 HOF
$3.99
View Details
Albert Abreu RC 2021 Topps Series One Baseball #88 MLB New York Yankees Pitcher
$1.20
View Details
Gerrit Cole/Luis Severino 2023 Topps One-Two Punch #12P8 New York Yankees
$1.50
View Details
2020 Topps Decades' Best #DB-76 Mariano Rivera New York Yankees
$1.49
View Details
2020 Topps Decades' Best Series 2 Inserts blue parallel *Free Shipping*
$2.94
View Details
2023 Topps Gerrit Cole / Luis Severino #12P-8 One-Two Punch New York Yankees 13K
$1.05
View Details
1996 Score Pitcher Perfect Randy Johnson/Alex Rodriguez 2 Mariners Yankees
$2.17
View Details
1988 DRAKE'S BIG HITTERS SUPER PITCHERS RICKEY HENDERSON NEW YORK YANKEES #7
$5.00
View Details
1973 Topps Rookie Pitchers - Norm Angelini/Steve Blateric/Mike Garman Rookie
$4.50
View Details
1987 DRAKE'S BIG HITTERS SUPER PITCHERS DON MATTINGLY NEW YORK YANKEES #8
$5.00
View Details
1928 Fro Joy Babe Ruth #2 ~Look out Mr. Pitcher~ BVG Beckett Authentic Altered
$2800.00
View Details
Lefty Gomez 1/1🔥NY Yankees 2 Color Patch Legendary Cuts #44 HOF Pitcher
$159.99
View Details
Gerrit Cole 2021 Topps Series One Baseball #95 MLB New York Yankees Pitcher
$1.00
View Details
New York Yankees 2021 Topps Rainbow Foil Pitchers 4 Card Lot Zack Britton
$4.99
View Details
Deivi Garcia 2021 Topps RC #41 PSA 9 Mint - New York Yankees - Pitcher
$15.00
View Details
1983 1984 TOPPS BASEBALL CARD #176 #635 DAVE RIGHETTI YANKEES PITCHER LOT OF 2
$5.00
View Details
Gerrit Cole Luis Severino 2023 Topps Series One #12P-8 ONE-TWO PUNCH YANKEES
$3.00
View Details
1977 Topps Baseball - Pick A Card - Cards 321-490
$3.49
View Details
2023 Topps One Two Punch Roger Clemens / Mike Mussina New York Yankees #12P-21
$2.09
View Details
1949 Bowman #236 Fred Sanford SGC 6 New York Yankees 2xWSC Pitcher High # StLou
$105.00
View Details
2024 Topps Series 2 Victor Wembanyama First Pitch New York Yankees FP-1 SGC 9
$24.99
View Details
2023 Topps #12P-21 Roger Clemens / Mike Mussina One-Two Punch - JF
$0.99
View Details
Philip Hughes rookie card lot (2) Phil Hughes New York Yankees Pitcher ⚾FreeShip
$1.59
View Details
2023 Topps One-Two Punch. Andy Pettitte / CC Sabathia #12P-4
$1.26
View Details
TOPPS 1962 VENEZUELA*RALPH*TERRY#48:2XW*S*CHAMP*WS*MVP*-SHELDON#185-GIFT:YANKEES
$15.00
View Details
2009 TOPPS TEAM SET NY YANKEES #NYY2 HOF MARIANO RIVERA PSA 10 POP 2 INAUGURAL
$48.36
View Details
2021 TOPPS COREY KLUBER #567 PITCHER NEW YORK YANKEES BASEBALL CARD
$1.39
View Details
2018 Topps High Tek Dwight Gooden New York Yankees Pitcher #HT-DGO Free Shipping
$3.99
View Details
2021 TOPPS DEIVI GARCIA #41 ROOKIE PITCHER NEW YORK YANKEES BASEBALL CARD
$1.39
View Details
TOPPS 2021 ALBERT ABREU #88 PITCHER NEW YORK YANKEES ROOKIE BASEBALL CARD
$1.39
View Details
2021 Topps Series One 1 /2021 Zack Britton #254 New York Yankees Pitcher
$1.99
View Details
1977 Galasso #25 Whitey Ford New York Yankees HOF ⚾️
$2.70
View Details
Roger Clemens Invincible 1999 Pitcher Sandlot Heroes Yankee MLB 11 Baseball Card
$1.00
View Details
Gerrit Cole / Luis Severino 2023 Topps One-Two Punch #12P-8 New York Yankees
$1.50
View Details
1988 Kenner Starting Lineup Cards #21 Roger Clemens Red Sox Yankees Pitcher
$2.50
View Details
1982 White w/ Blue Border Back Whitey Ford New York Yankees #3 (No MLB Logo)
$1.99
View Details
2021 TOPPS CLARKE SCHMIDT #456 ROOKIE PITCHER NEW YORK YANKEES BASEBALL CARD
$1.39
View Details
Aroldis Chapman 2021 Topps Series One Baseball #157 MLB New York Yankees Pitcher
$1.00
View Details
1988 Fleer Baseball's Best Sluggers vs Pitchers Don Mattingly New York Yankees
$1.25
View Details
Gerrit Cole / Luis Severino 2023 Topps #12P-8 One-Two Punch New York Yankees
$1.91
View Details
2023 Topps One-Two Punch Roger Clemens / Andy Pettitte #12P-6 New York Yankees
$1.40
View Details
2020 Topps Series 1 and Series 2 DECADES BEST CHROME You Pick
$1.99
View Details
Jimmy Key 1994 Donruss Motion Marvels & 1994 Topps All Stars - Yankees
$0.99
View Details
2020 Topps Update # DB-49 Andy Pettitte New York Yankees
$1.65
View Details
Domingo Acevedo New York Yankees 2018 Bowman Baseball Prospects Card
$1.25
View Details
2023 Topps GERRIT COLE International Trading Card Day NYY-5 YANKEE STADIUM PROMO
$5.99
View Details
1990 Chuck Cary Lot NM+ New York Yankees Pitcher Upper Deck 528, Topps 691
$2.48
View Details
Deivi Garcia RC 2021 Topps Series One Baseball #41 MLB New York Yankees Pitcher
$1.40
View Details
Deivi Garcia RC 2021 Topps Baseball Opening Day #13 MLB New York Yankees Pitcher
$1.25
View Details
2020 Topps Update Whitey Ford Decades' Best #DB-1 New York Yankees
$1.00
View Details
2020 Topps Series 1 / Series 2 / Update DECADES BEST Black Blue Green You Pick
$3.50
View Details
Carlos Rodon 043/199 Autographed 2014 Prizm Perennial Draft Picks Press Proof
$9.99
View Details
2 1986 & 1987 Topps Baseball Ron Guidry New York Yankees MLB Pitcher
$1.50
View Details
MLB MAJOR LEAGUE BASEBALL AUTO AUTOGRAPH AUTOGRAPHED SIGNED PICK PLAYER CARD
$4.00
View Details
2023 Topps One Two Punch #12P-21 Roger Clemens & Mike Mussina NY Yankees
$1.25
View Details
MLB - Jimmy Key 1994 Donruss & 1994 Topps All Stars - Yankees
$0.99
View Details
TOPPS 2021 JAMES PAXTON #542 PITCHER NEW YORK YANKEES BASEBALL CARD
$1.39
View Details
Roger Clemens / Mike Mussina 2023 Topps: One-Two Punch #12P-21 New York Yankees
$1.48
View Details
2023 Topps One-Two Punch New York Yankees Roger Clemens Andy Pettitte #12P-6
$1.35
View Details
2020 Topps Update Decades' Best Inserts #DB-....... Complete Your Set
$1.29
View Details
2020 Topps Decades' Best Series 2 Blue #DB11 Whitey Ford
$1.00
View Details
Roger Clemens Mike Mussina 2023 Topps One-Two Punch New York Yankees
$1.49
View Details
2023 TOPPS SERIES 1 💥 ALL ACES 💥 INSERT PARALLEL MLB Aces 🔶 Shohei Ohtani 🔶
$13.50
View Details
2021 Leaf Metal Alexander Vizcaino Auto Rookie Silver Mojo NYY/CUBS pitcher
$1.50
View Details
2021 TOPPS ZACK BRITTON #254 PITCHER NEW YORK YANKEES BASEBALL CARD
$1.40
View Details
2022 TOPPS LUIS SEVERINO #533 PITCHER NEW YORK YANKEES BASEBALL CARD
$1.49
View Details
TOPPS 2021 GERRIT COLE #95 PITCHER NEW YORK YANKEES BASEBALL CARD
$1.69
View Details
2023 Topps One-Two Punch Red Gerrit Cole/Luis Severino 09/10 New York Yankees
$7.50
View Details
2020 Topps Update #DB-49 Andy Pettitte New York Yankees Decades' Best
$1.99
View Details
Domingo Acevedo New York Yankees 2016 Bowman Prospect
$1.50
View Details
2023 Topps #12P-6 Roger Clemens / Andy Pettitte One-Two Punch New York Yankees
$2.99
View Details
2020 Topps #DB-68 Goose Gossage Decades' Best (Series 2) New York Yankees
$1.75
View Details
1982 TCMA BASEBALL'S GREATEST PITCHERS - #13 ALLIE REYNOLDS - YANKEES -
$1.00
View Details
2022 TOPPS STEPHEN RIDINGS #516 ROOKIE PITCHER NEW YORK YANKEES BASEBALL CARD
$1.45
View Details
Tommy John 1988 Fleer & 1988 Donruss Baseball - Yankees
$0.99
View Details
Domingo Acevedo New York Yankees 2019 Bowman Baseball Prospects Card
$1.25
View Details
1982 TCMA BASEBALL'S GREATEST PITCHERS - #20 LEFTY GOMEZ - YANKEES -
$1.00
View Details
2023 Topps #12P-8 One-Two Punch /299 New York Yankees
$5.09
View Details
1988 DRAKE'S BIG HITTERS SUPER PITCHERS WILLIE RANDOLPH NEW YORK YANKEES #18
$5.00
View Details